EUR-Lex & EU Commission AI-Powered Semantic Search Engine
Modern Legal
  • Query in any language with multilingual search
  • Access EUR-Lex and EU Commission case law
  • See relevant paragraphs highlighted instantly
Start free trial

Similar Documents

Explore similar documents to your case.

We Found Similar Cases for You

Sign up for free to view them and see the most relevant paragraphs highlighted.

Judgment of the Civil Service Tribunal (First Chamber) of 28 April 2009. # Marie-Thérèse Balieu-Steinmetz and Lidia Noworyta v European Parliament. # Public service - Officials - Remuneration - Equal treatment. # Case F-115/07.

ECLI:EU:F:2009:41

62007FJ0115

April 28, 2009
With Google you find a lot.
With us you find everything. Try it now!

I imagine what I want to write in my case, I write it in the search engine and I get exactly what I wanted. Thank you!

Valentina R., lawyer

(Civil service – Officials – Remuneration – Fixed allowance for overtime – Article 3 of Annex VI to the Staff Regulations – Article 56 of the Staff Regulations – Internal rules on the fixed allowance for overtime – Internal rules on compensation for overtime – Equal treatment)

Application: brought under Articles 236 EC and 152 EA, in which Ms Balieu-Steinmetz and Ms Noworyta seek, first, a declaration that the first article of the internal rules concerning the fixed allowance for overtime adopted by the Parliament’s Secretary-General pursuant to Article 3 of Annex VI to the Staff Regulations is illegal, and second, annulment of the Parliament’s implied decision of 13 November 2006 rejecting Ms Balieu-Steinmetz’s request of 13 July 2006, and the Parliament’s decision of 18 December 2006 rejecting Ms Noworyta’s request of 5 July 2006, both requests seeking payment of the abovementioned fixed allowance.

Held: The Parliament’s implied decision of 13 November 2006 rejecting Ms Balieu-Steinmetz’s request of 13 July 2006, and the Parliament’s decision of 18 December 2006 rejecting Ms Noworyta’s request of 5 July 2006 are annulled. The Parliament is to bear all the costs.

Summary

(Art. 236 EC; Staff Regulations, Art. 90)

1.The Civil Service Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate on claims directly seeking a declaration that a measure of general application, such as a provision of the Staff Regulations, is illegal.

(see para. 20)

2.An institution’s decision refusing to grant a fixed allowance to an official even though other officials in a comparable situation receive it, a decision which is based on the unlawful nature of the payment of that allowance to the latter officials, infringes the principle of equal treatment where the institution cannot satisfactorily prove that the payment of the allowance to those officials has no legal basis, since measures adopted by the Community institutions are presumed to be lawful.

(see paras 28-30, 32, 36, 42)

See:

188/83 Witte v Parliament [1984] ECR 3465, paras 13 to 15

T-30/90 Zoder v Parliament [1991] ECR II‑207, para. 26; T-272/94 Brulant v Parliament [1996] ECR-SC I‑A‑513 and II‑1397, para. 35; T-22/99 Rose v Commission [2000] ECR-SC I‑A‑27 and II‑115, para. 39; T-157/99 Griesel v Council [2000] ECR-SC I‑A‑151 and II‑699, para. 25; judgment of 8 July 2003 in T-65/02 Chetaud v Parliament, not published in the ECR, para. 44; T-120/04 Peróxidos Orgánicos v Commission [2006] ECR II‑4441, para. 77; T-379/04 J v Commission [2006] ECR-SC I‑A‑2‑313 and II‑A‑2‑1575, para. 79

F-4/07 Skoulidi v Commission [2008] ECR-SC I‑A‑1‑0000 and II‑A‑1‑0000, para. 81

EurLex Case Law

AI-Powered Case Law Search

Query in any language with multilingual search
Access EUR-Lex and EU Commission case law
See relevant paragraphs highlighted instantly

Get Instant Answers to Your Legal Questions

Cancel your subscription anytime, no questions asked.Start 14-Day Free Trial

At Modern Legal, we’re building the world’s best search engine for legal professionals. Access EU and global case law with AI-powered precision, saving you time and delivering relevant insights instantly.

Contact Us

Tivolska cesta 48, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia